FishOutFishOut
vsRedreach

Comparison

FishOut vs Redreach

Redreach is the closest thing to FishOut among the Reddit tools: it scores relevance, suggests replies it never posts, and gives your AI assistant the same data over MCP and REST. The differences are the number of places it listens, the number of seats, and the fact that you can read FishOut’s price before you talk to anyone.

Redreach facts checked on 20 October 2026, from their own published material. Sources are listed at the foot of this page.

 FishOutRedreach
Platforms
10
Reddit only
Price
Published, from Free
Not published
MCP + API
Every plan, incl. Free
Yes; plan not published
[01] AT A GLANCE/ SIDE BY SIDE

FishOut and Redreach, feature by feature

Ties are marked as ties, and Redreach's wins as wins.
FishOut compared with Redreach, feature by feature
 FishOutRedreach
Coverage
PlatformsAdvantage: 10Behind: Reddit only
RedditBehind: Every plan, hourlyAdvantage: Yes, plus Google-ranking threads
AI
Relevance on every postAdvantage: Yes, with the reason and a Filtered viewBehind: Relevance score
Reply suggestionsEven: Drafts in your Voice, never postedEven: AI-guided replies, never posted
SetupEven: Website read, then a keyword list you reviewEven: Website and three competitors, no keywords
Alerts
Alert destinationsAdvantage: 13, every planBehind: Email, Slack, Telegram, webhook
Developer
MCP server — which planAdvantage: Every plan, including FreeBehind: Offered; plan not published
REST API — which planAdvantage: Every plan, including FreeBehind: Offered; plan not published
Team
Seats at entryAdvantage: Unlimited on every planBehind: 1 / 2 / 3 by plan
Price
Published priceAdvantage: Free, then $19/moBehind: Not published
Free planAdvantage: Free forever, 10 keywords, 500 relevant/moBehind: None; paid 3-day pass
RefundsEven: Cancel any time; Free costs nothingEven: 48-hour money-back
Sales call neededEven: No — self-serve, cancel any timeEven: No for listed plans; agencies via sales
[02] WHAT IT COSTS/ SAME NEED

What each need costs on FishOut and on Redreach

The plan you would need on each side for the thing you came for.
To getFishOutRedreach
A price before a purchaseFreeFreeNot published
Four people on one accountFreeFreeQuote only
MCP and RESTFreeFreeNot published
Hacker News and GitHubFreeFreeNot offered

Monthly-billed. A keyword is not always the same unit on both sides.

[03] WHERE REDREACH IS STRONGER/ HONESTLY
Redreach is Reddit lead generation set up from your website, and there are things it does that we do not.

Threads that rank on Google

Redreach surfaces Reddit threads that already rank in Google search, which is where a reply keeps paying off for months. FishOut reads new conversations; it does not measure search ranking.

Setup without keywords

Redreach builds its search from your website and three competitors. FishOut’s onboarding also reads your website and proposes keywords, but you review and keep a keyword list — more control, a step more work.

A 48-hour money-back guarantee

Redreach refunds within 48 hours of payment and sells a 3-day pass. A guarantee is a fair way to lower the risk of a paid-only product.
[04] WHERE FISHOUT WINS/ WITH PROOF

The same MCP idea, across ten platforms

Ask your assistant “who asked for a tool like ours this week?” and Redreach answers from Reddit. FishOut answers from Reddit, Hacker News, Bluesky, GitHub, Google News and, on paid plans, LinkedIn, TikTok, YouTube and Medium.
Sources
Reddit
X
LinkedIn
Bluesky
Hacker News
YouTube
TikTok
Medium
GitHub
Google News

A price you can read

Redreach’s plans are Startup, Growth and Professional, and its site shows no figure for any of them on 20 October 2026. FishOut is Free, $19, $49 or $99 a month, on a public page, with no call.

Seats that do not run out

Redreach is one, two or three seats by plan, with more through sales. FishOut has no seat limit on any plan.

Every post explained, not just scored

Both tools score relevance. FishOut shows the reason with it — Matches your brief, Asking for a tool, Not answered yet — and keeps what it filtered in a view you can check, so you can see what you are not seeing.
Why this is relevant
96
Matches your briefAsking for helpNot answered yetFresh
Reply nowAsking for recommendationsHas a problem
[05] WHO SHOULD PICK WHICH/ SHORTCUTS

If you…

Who we would send to Redreach, and who to us.
Reddit threads that rank on Google are the prizeRedreachIt finds them directly; we do not measure search ranking.
You want setup with no keyword list at allRedreachIt works from your website and competitors. Ours proposes keywords and asks you to keep them.
You want MCP and an API over more than Reddit, at a price you can seeFishOutTen platforms, MCP and REST on Free, and plans from $19/mo with unlimited seats.
[06] IN AND OUT/ 10 SOURCES · 13 DESTINATIONS

10 places to listen

Redreach: 1 (Reddit). FishOut: Reddit, Hacker News, Bluesky, GitHub and Google News hourly on every plan, five more on paid plans.
Reddit
X
LinkedIn
Bluesky
Hacker News
YouTube
TikTok
Medium
GitHub
Google News

13 places to be told

Redreach: Email, Slack, Telegram, webhook. FishOut: all 13, on every plan.
Slack
Teams
Google Chat
Discord
Telegram
Mattermost
ntfy
Feishu
DingTalk
WeCom
Zapier
Email
Webhook
[07] SEE IT ON YOUR KEYWORDS/ FREE PLAN

What you get instead of Redreach

Where Redreach stops at the match, the inbox keeps going: why it matters, whether to answer, and the answer drafted in your voice.
Leads· Best first14
83
TikTok@founderdiaries1d

Comment on: How I answer 300 customer emails a week alone

Reply nowQuestionAsking for recommendations
92
Hacker Newslindqvist3h

Ask HN: Shared inbox for a five-person support team?

Reply nowAsking for recommendationsQuestion
87
Hacker Newskestrel_ops50m

Show HN: We replaced our helpdesk with a shared Gmail and a script

Reply, carefullyQuestion
TikTok@founderdiaries1d

Comment on: How I answer 300 customer emails a week alone

What app is that inbox in the video? It looks like it sorts by who is waiting longest.

Relevance

83
Asks about the productBuying signalFresh

Labels · Reply call

Reply nowQuestionAsking for recommendations

Name it, one line

Draft reply

That is AcmeMail — I work on it. Sort by waiting time is under Views.

  • Says who you are
  • Short enough for a comment
Copy and open threadFishOut never posts

Questions

Sources

  • FishOut pricing — checked 19 October 2026. lib/pricing-data.ts — the same data the pricing page renders.
  • Redreach homepage, pricing section and FAQ — checked 20 October 2026. No prices in the rendered pricing section; /pricing returns 404. Plans Startup (1 seat), Growth (2) and Professional (3); more seats, agencies and white-label through contact sales. A one-time 3-day pass (price not shown) and a money-back guarantee within 48 hours of payment. Reddit only, including Reddit threads that rank on Google. Alerts by email, Slack, Telegram and webhook. Relevance score per post, setup from your website and three competitors rather than keywords, AI-guided replies it does not post. "Connect your AI assistant to Redreach with a single key… The same data is one REST call away."

Product names and logos belong to their owners and are used only to identify the products compared. No endorsement is implied.