FishOutFishOut
vsHotMention

Comparison

FishOut vs HotMention

The most like-for-like comparison in this group. Both read each post for intent, give a verdict on whether to answer, draft a reply you post yourself, and ship an MCP server and an API. HotMention is one $99 plan covering six platforms, including Threads and Quora. FishOut covers a different ten, starts free, and charges $19 for the same 50 keywords.

HotMention facts checked on 20 October 2026, from their own published material. Sources are listed at the foot of this page.

 FishOutHotMention
Starts at
Free
$99/mo
Keywords at entry
50 for $19
50 for $99
Platforms
10
6, incl. Threads, Quora
[01] AT A GLANCE/ SIDE BY SIDE

FishOut and HotMention, feature by feature

Ties are marked as ties, and HotMention's wins as wins.
FishOut compared with HotMention, feature by feature
 FishOutHotMention
Coverage
PlatformsDifferent sets: Threads and Quora are theirs; HN, GitHub, Bluesky, Medium, News are oursEven: 10Even: 6: Reddit, X, LinkedIn, Threads, Quora, YouTube
RedditEven: Every plan, hourlyEven: Yes
AI
Intent on every postEven: Relevance 0–100 with the reasonEven: 0–100 score across five factors
Whether to answerEven: Reply call: Reply now, carefully, Watch, SkipEven: Reply / Careful / Skip
Reply draftsBehind: Plus and up, capped by planAdvantage: Unlimited
Reply verification after postingBehind: Not offeredAdvantage: Day 1, 3 and 7
Alerts
Alert destinationsAdvantage: 13, every planBehind: Slack, Telegram, webhook, email
Price per alert destination at entryEntry price divided by the destinations it includesAdvantage: $0 on Free; $1.46 on PlusBehind: $24.75 ($99 ÷ 4)
Developer
MCP server — which planEven: Every plan, including FreeEven: Every plan — its one $99 plan
REST API — which planEven: Every plan, including FreeEven: Every plan — its one $99 plan
Team
Seats at entryAdvantage: Unlimited on every planBehind: 3
Price
Entry priceAdvantage: Free, then $19/moBehind: $99/mo, one plan
KeywordsAdvantage: 50 at $19/mo; 200 at $49/moBehind: 50, then +25 for $20/mo
Free plan or trialAdvantage: Free forever, 10 keywords, 500 relevant/moBehind: 3-day trial, no card
Sales call neededEven: No — self-serve, cancel any timeEven: No — 3-day trial, no card
[02] WHAT IT COSTS/ SAME NEED

What each need costs on FishOut and on HotMention

The plan you would need on each side for the thing you came for.
To getFishOutHotMention
50 keywords$19/moPlus$99/moPro
200 keywords$49/moPro$219/moPro + 6 keyword packs
MCP and an APIFreeFree$99/moPro
Threads or Quora—Not offered$99/moPro

Monthly-billed. A keyword is not always the same unit on both sides.

[03] WHERE HOTMENTION IS STRONGER/ HONESTLY
HotMention is buyer-intent leads from six platforms, and the threads AI cites, and there are things it does that we do not.

Threads and Quora

HotMention covers Reddit, X, LinkedIn, Threads, Quora and YouTube. FishOut does not cover Threads or Quora at all. If those are where your buyers are, HotMention reaches them and we do not.

Reply verification and a reply budget

HotMention checks on day 1, 3 and 7 whether your reply is still live, rates how safe a subreddit is to post in, and lets you cap replies per day. Those are thoughtful guard-rails we do not have.

AI-citation tracking

It tracks which threads ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity and Claude cite, and adds them to the lead feed. FishOut reads the conversations; it does not measure what an assistant says.
[04] WHERE FISHOUT WINS/ WITH PROOF

The same shape from $0

HotMention’s 0–100 intent score and Reply / Careful / Skip verdict map closely onto FishOut’s relevance and Reply call — parity, said plainly. The difference is price: FishOut Free has triage and MCP, and 50 keywords are $19/mo against 50 at $99.
Why this is relevant
96
Matches your briefAsking for helpNot answered yetFresh
Reply nowAsking for recommendationsHas a problem

Where developers talk

Hacker News, GitHub, Bluesky, Medium and Google News are FishOut sources and not HotMention ones. For a developer tool, those are often the threads that convert.
Sources
Reddit
X
LinkedIn
Bluesky
Hacker News
YouTube
TikTok
Medium
GitHub
Google News

More keywords for less as you grow

Two hundred keywords is FishOut Pro at $49/mo. On HotMention it is the $99 plan plus six +25-keyword add-ons at $20 each, $219 a month.
To get 50 keywords

FishOut

Plus, $19/mo

Them

Pro, $99/mo

Thirteen destinations, unlimited seats

HotMention delivers to Slack, Telegram, webhooks and email, with three seats. FishOut delivers to 13 destinations with no seat limit.
[05] WHO SHOULD PICK WHICH/ SHORTCUTS

If you…

Who we would send to HotMention, and who to us.
Your buyers are on Threads, Quora or XHotMentionIt covers all three today. We cover none of them yet.
You want guard-rails on how often you replyHotMentionReply budgets, subreddit safety ratings and reply verification are built in.
Your buyers are developers, or $99 is a lot for one channelFishOutHacker News, GitHub and Bluesky included, from Free, and 50 keywords for $19/mo.
[06] IN AND OUT/ 10 SOURCES · 13 DESTINATIONS

10 places to listen

HotMention: 6. FishOut: Reddit, Hacker News, Bluesky, GitHub and Google News hourly on every plan, five more on paid plans.
Reddit
X
LinkedIn
Bluesky
Hacker News
YouTube
TikTok
Medium
GitHub
Google News

13 places to be told

HotMention: Slack, Telegram, webhook, email. FishOut: all 13, on every plan.
Slack
Teams
Google Chat
Discord
Telegram
Mattermost
ntfy
Feishu
DingTalk
WeCom
Zapier
Email
Webhook
[07] SEE IT ON YOUR KEYWORDS/ FREE PLAN

What you get instead of HotMention

This is the free plan. Instead of a feed of matches, a list sorted by who is asking — and unlike HotMention, alerts go to whichever of thirteen places your team reads.
Leads· Best first14
78
MediumShip Small2d

The five tools I would buy again for a two-person startup

WatchComparison
89
Blueskymara.builds5h

Comparing Notchmail and AcmeMail for our team this week

Reply, carefullyComparison
83
TikTok@founderdiaries1d

Comment on: How I answer 300 customer emails a week alone

Reply nowQuestionAsking for recommendations
MediumShip Small2d

The five tools I would buy again for a two-person startup

Number three is a shared inbox. The author says they tried AcmeMail and Notchmail and “never finished the comparison”.

Relevance

78
Names youComparisonEvergreen

Labels · Reply call

WatchComparison

No reply; add to the comparison doc

Draft reply

No public reply suggested. Saved to the Comparisons view for the next content round.

  • No public reply needed
Copy and open threadFishOut never posts

Questions

Sources

  • FishOut pricing — checked 19 October 2026. lib/pricing-data.ts — the same data the pricing page renders.
  • HotMention homepage and pricing section — checked 20 October 2026. One plan, Pro, $99/mo; annual is "2 months free". 50 keywords, 500 scored leads a month, unlimited projects, 3 seats. Reddit, X, LinkedIn, Threads, Quora and YouTube. 0–100 score across intent, relevance, freshness, competition and visibility, with a Reply / Careful / Skip verdict and drafts; never posts for you. Slack, Telegram, webhook and email. API and MCP access on Pro (11 MCP tools), plus a CLI. Add-ons: +250 leads or +25 keywords, $20/mo each. 3-day trial, no credit card. AI-citation tracking across ChatGPT, AI Overviews, Perplexity and Claude.

Product names and logos belong to their owners and are used only to identify the products compared. No endorsement is implied.